.jpg)
Last Week: 5-2
Overall: 15-20
Colorado State +5.5 San Diego State
San Diego State has had a weird start to the 2025 season. Not bad or good, just weird. They have won three games which equals their win total from last season, but the results have been all over the place. They have recorded two shutout wins during which they have scored 72 total points, with one coming against an FCS team and the other an ACC team that is otherwise unbeaten. They also won an ugly 6-3 game against a MAC school and in their only loss allowed 36 points to a team that has not scored more than 24 points in any other game this season. Insert shoulder shrug emoji here. Now they open conference play against a team set to join them in whatever they are calling the new Pac-12 next year. Colorado State is just 1-3 through the first third of the season, with their lone win coming against an FCS opponent. However, they have played a strong power conference team (Washington), a solid Group of Five team (UTSA), and a future Pac-whatever team (Washington State). The loss to UTSA came by a single point and in their loss to Washington State, they scored only three points despite multiple drives that ended in Washington State territory. They failed on fourth down three times, including once inside the Cougar ten yard line. They fumbled inside the Cougar twenty yard line. Plus they also missed two field goals. Turnovers, fourth down failures, and missed kicks contribute significantly to the outcome of one game, but are not very useful for predicting what will happen next. San Diego State has scored four offensive touchdowns in their three games against FBS opponents. That is not a recipe for covering spreads as a favorite unless the Aztecs are counting on some defensive or special teams touchdowns. I think this game ends up like a classic 1970s NFL game. Not necessarily in style of play, but in final score. A final of 17-14, 20-17, or 21-17 seems quite likely. Take the undervalued dog against the overvalued favorite.
Ball State +14.5 Ohio
The Mike Uremovich era began rather inauspiciously at Ball State. The Cardinals lost their first two games (against power conference teams) by a combined score of 73-3 and generated under 300 total yards combined. However, since the schedule has eased up, the Cardinals have scored 34 and 25 respectively against a solid FCS team (New Hampshire) and mid-level non-power FBS team (Connecticut). The Cardinals also rang up over 400 yards of offense in each game. They were especially strong on the ground, rolling up nearly 500 combined yards rushing after being held to negative rushing yards by Auburn. Now the Cardinals open MAC play off a bye against a team that is potentially the league's best. In a rugged non-conference slate, the defending MAC champs went 1-2 against a trio of power conference teams (beat West Virginia). In their non-conference finale, they beat an FCS team (Gardner-Webb) and then opened MAC play with a two touchdown victory against Bowling Green. The Bobcats have the best quarterback in the MAC (Parker Navarro), but their run defense has been suspect. In the past two weeks, Gardner-Webb and Bowling Green have each rushed for nearly 200 yards against the Bobcats at over five yards per carry. That plays right into the hands of a big underdog. Expect Ball State to keep the ball on the ground and chew up the clock against Ohio. As previously mentioned, the Cardinals are also off a bye, while Ohio is playing a game for the sixth consecutive week. Catching double digits at home, the Cardinals are the play.
Wisconsin +17.5 Michigan
I like the Badgers in this spot for a couple of reasons. For starters, they have played good run defense through the first quarter of the season. Opponents are averaging just over two yards per carry and while that includes two games against Miami of Ohio and Middle Tennessee, it also includes their showings against Alabama and Maryland. Alabama rushed for 72 yards on 22 carries against the Badgers which represents the high water mark their defense has permitted in both yardage and yards per carry (3.27). Their pass defense has been another story (allowed over eight yards per pass), but that is skewed by Alabama's evisceration of their secondary. Michigan still has a (relatively) unproven freshman quarterback and will attempt to win this game on the ground. They romped through Nebraska in their last game, averaging over eight yards per carry and have rushed for over 1000 yards through their first four games. I think they will meet some resistance against the Badgers and be forced into more passing situations than they are comfortable with. Second, this spread is an historical outlier in this series. The Badgers and Wolverines have played twelve times since 2005 and Wisconsin has actually been favored seven times, including each of the past three meetings. Michigan has not been close to this big a favorite since they were favored by thirteen points in 2006. Finally, Wisconsin is coming off a bye after two consecutive horrendous performances. With four teams currently ranked in the AP Poll left on their schedule, not to mention games against Iowa, Washington, and Minnesota, Wisconsin is probably going to finish 4-8 or worse. However, with the bye week to reset, I expect a spirited effort on Saturday. The only issue I have with taking the Badgers is the dual questions of how do they and how much can they score? Outside of Middle Tennessee, Wisconsin has not scored more than seventeen points in any game this season. Still, with both teams deferring to the running game, the clock should be consistently running, so if they can score ten points, they should cover this number.
Massachusetts +13.5 Western Michigan
So its come to this? We are backing the Minutemen of Massachusetts. I understand if you don't have the stomach to take a winless team that somehow lost to Bryant (not Kobe or Paul Bear). But hear me out. Since losing to Bryant, the Minutemen have played Iowa and Missouri, and not particularly well, I might add. But what can we really tell from those games? Massachusetts is totally outclassed by those Big 10 and SEC teams. Now they get to face a team in their own weight class, at home no less. And rest assured, Western Michigan is in their weight class. The Broncos have won their past two games and thanks to their inexplicable win against Toledo are tied for first in the MAC. Despite scoring 47 points last week against Rhode Island, the Broncos have yet to eclipse five yards per play in any game this season. Their victory against Toledo says more about the Rockets and their volatility in MAC play (look at Jason Candle's record as a favorite) than it does about Western Michigan's quality. The Broncos have been a road favorite four previous times under Lance Taylor. They are 2-2 ATS in those games, but the covers have come in games where they were a one and three point favorite respectively. In the other games where they were favored by seven and ten points, they lost one outright and won the other by three. I'm not sure if the Minutemen can notch their first MAC win since 2015 (don't worry, they were out of the league for a decade and are not riding an eighty game losing skid), but they will cover this ridiculously high number.
Louisiana-Monroe +11.5 Northwestern
Last week I faded Northwestern when they were a decent sized home favorite against UCLA. The Wildcats stormed out to a 17-0 lead in the first half, but did not score again and had to hold on for dear life against the Bruins. The Wildcats have one of the worst passing games of all power conference teams. Quarterback Preston Stone, who threw 28 touchdown passes two seasons ago for SMU, has thrown exactly one touchdown pass in three games against FBS opponents (versus six interceptions). The Wildcats have scored three, fourteen, and seventeen points against FBS competition. The optimist might point out those point totals have been steadily increasing and expect continued improvement. They might be right. Sort of. It would not shock me if Northwestern scores or even eclipses twenty points on Saturday. However, I would not expect them to score much more than that. The oddsmakers and betting market don't either. The total in this game is forty and a half implying the Wildcats are expected to score around 25 points. That seems a little sanguine to me. Louisiana-Monroe plays like you want a double digit underdog to play. They have run the ball nearly 64% of the time in 2025 and they have done so quite well. The Warhawks are averaging nearly six yards per carry, and that total includes their low output against Alabama. The Warhawks will not be nearly as overmatched against the Wildcats. Northwestern has allowed over five yards per carry on the season and that includes their game against one of the worst teams in FCS (Western Illinois). The Wildcats have a road trip at Penn State next week, but they better not look past a Louisiana-Monroe team that is capable of pulling the outright upset in Evanston.
Michigan State +11.5 Nebraska
Nebraska has been a big favorite numerous times over the past few seasons. However, most of those instances have come against teams outside the power conferences. Since Scott Frost's arrival in 2018 and continuing through the Matt Rhule era, the Cornhuskers have been double digit favorites against power conference teams just six times (all Big 10 opponents). They are a respectable 3-3 ATS in such games, but the covers have come against Illinois in 2018 (4-8 record), Northwestern in 2021 (3-9), and Purdue last season (1-11). Against more respectable opponents (Illinois in 2019 and 2020 and Northwestern in 2023), the Cornhuskers have failed to cover and have even lost outright. Michigan State will not be participating in the College Football Playoff this season, but the Spartans are 3-1 and have an outside shot at a bowl game. And like Nebraska, they are off a bye after their first loss of the season. Michigan State should be able to take advantage of Nebraska's poor run defense. The two power conference teams Nebraska has faced (Cincinnati and Michigan) rushed for nearly 500 yards at over seven yards per clip. Michigan State has been decent on the ground, averaging around 130 yards per game at nearly four yards per carry against their two power conference opponents. In addition, Michigan State head coach Jonathan Smith has been an underdog covering machine at both Corvallis and East Lansing. His teams at Oregon State and Michigan State are a combined 17-9 ATS as a road underdog. Nebraska should not be favored against any Big 10 team by double digits save perhaps Northwestern and maybe Purdue. Take the Spartans to give the Cornhuskers all they can handle in Lincoln.
Florida State +4.5 Miami
Last week I faded Florida State as they were playing their first road game against a quality opponent after a month at home. Miami is in an eerily similar situation this week. The Hurricanes pulled a narrow upset over Notre Dame in their opener and have not been challenged since against a trio of in-state teams of varying quality (Bethune-Cookman, South Florida, and Florida). The Hurricane offense wrecked Bethune-Cookman and South Florida (over 1100 combined yards), but against the two power conference teams on their schedule (Notre Dame and Florida), they have averaged under five yards per play. Florida State's defense suffered some breakdowns last week against Virginia, but the Seminoles actually outgained the Cavaliers by 74 yards and averaged a yard more per play. Florida State had a fluky interception inside the Virginia red zone and seemed ready to take control of the game after spotting Virginia a 14-0 lead. Last week's loss to the Cavaliers was tough, but the Seminoles are still alive in both the ACC race and the College Football Playoff. I expect them to be motivated when their unbeaten in-state rival travels to Tallahassee. Miami is a shade overrated by the betting public (Notre Dame's best defensive performance by both total yards and yards per play came against the Hurricanes) and as they venture away from home, I expect another top ten team to go down.
No comments:
Post a Comment