Last Week: 2-5
Overall: 37-37-3
East Carolina +6 Army
East Carolina has the second best per play defense in the American Conference as well as the second best run defense (both per play and total per game). However, their offense has been one of the worst in the conference which has hindered their ability to contend. At 4-2, the Pirates are still technically alive in the race, but they need some help to get to the conference title game. Their tight win against Charlotte last week has got to be culprit for this betting line because the Pirates seem like they were designed in a lab to beat Army. As previously mentioned the Pirates have a great run defense. They also lead the nation in tackles for loss and should be able to put Army in several uncomfortable third and long situations. Meanwhile, Army's defense is among the worst in the American, allowing nearly seven yards per play. East Carolina should hold the Army offense down while generating one of their better offensive performances of the season. The wrong team is favored here, so back the Pirates catching nearly a touchdown.
Louisiana-Monroe +14 Appalachian State
The Mountaineers won at Marshall last week, notching their sixth win of the season. The victory means App will finish with at least six regular season wins for the first time since 2023! This formerly dominant FCS power and Sun Belt contender has fallen on hard times. This spread does not reflect that. The Mountaineers won the Sun Belt East and played for the conference title in 2023. That season, they finished 5-1 in Kidd Brewer Stadium with all five of their victories coming by double digits. Since the start of the 2024 season, the Mountaineers are just 10-6 at home (7-6 against FBS opponents). In those thirteen games against FBS opponents, they have won by double digits just once. Tight wins against less than stellar competition has become the norm and I would not expect this game to deviate from that script. Since upsetting James Madison about a month ago, the Mountaineers have scored 3, 23, and 20 points in their past three games. Its hard to win by two touchdowns when you rarely score more than three yourself.
NC State +10 Florida State
Rick Stockstill (formerly the longtime head coach of Middle Tennessee State) is unbeaten as the interim head coach at Florida State. The Seminoles won road contests at Boston College and Pittsburgh. In those two games, they outgained the Eagles and Panthers by 0.26 yards per play. Those are solid numbers, but they are not going to spring forth memories of the Seminoles from the 90s. Let's not forget that Boston College is near the bottom of the ACC standings and Pittsburgh has almost no passing game to speak of since losing Mason Heintschel to injury a month and a half ago. Off those two wins, now the betting market expects Florida State to win by double digits against another team with an interim coach. The Wolfpack fired Dave Doeren after a Friday night loss at Stanford and after winning their first game under interim Todd Goebbel, have dropped their past two. In three games under Goebbel, the Wolfpack have been outgained by .03 yards per play. Those aren't great numbers, but they are much better than the full season numbers for NC State (outgained by about a yard per play by ACC foes in totality). I see two teams that have not quit on their interim coaching staffs, but one team has a lot more respect in the betting market. Take the Wolfpack to keep this one close and don't be surprised if they spring an outright upset in Tallahassee.
Maryland +17.5 Southern Cal
They should have fired Mike Locksley ages ago. Since firing Locks, the Terrapins have won two of three, with every game coming down to the wire. In those three games, Maryland has outgained Illinois, Purdue, and Wisconsin by 0.73 yards per play. Neither of those three teams are great, but they are at least average or slightly below in terms of Big 10 quality. Southern Cal represents a step up in class, but the Trojans are far from elite themselves. The Trojans are actually underwater in terms of net yards per play in Big 10 action, having been outgained by their seven conference opponents by 0.18 yards per play. Their four Big 10 wins have come by seven points at Rutgers, four points against Washington at home, eight points at Penn State, and twelve points in their best showing against Ohio State and their backup quarterback in Los Angeles. Nothing they have shown this season outside of their shutout against Fresno State has shown they have the capability to beat a rejuvenated Maryland by three scores. Back the Terrapins as Southern Cal is basically out of the College Football Playoff race and playing out another disappointing season under Lincoln Riley.
SMU +20.5 Notre Dame
One of the hardest thing to do when handicapping football games is to back a team that looked horrible in their previous game. And few teams looked more horrible than SMU. Playing at home with a chance to tighten up the ACC race and start their own darkhorse College Football Playoff journey, SMU was down six touchdowns at halftime on their way to a 49-7 loss. Part of that was poor play on SMU's part, but part of it was also their opponent. Wake Forest did to SMU what they have done to their previous six opponents, force them to abandon all hope at halftime. I'm not going to try and convince you that Wake Forest is 1995 Nebraska, but the Demon Deacons have at least played like one of the best five teams in college football since the calendar turned to October. Could Notre Dame represent a downturn in schedule strength for the Mustangs? Such a thought would have been blasphemous (and could still be) at the start of the season. Based on the latest College Football Playoff rankings, Notre Dame just needs to win their final two games before cruising into the postseason. Marcus Freeman has never blown a home game he was supposed to dominate right? I'm not saying SMU is going to win, but I expect a more focused effort and a better performance as the Mustangs stay within three touchdowns.
Utah State +9.5 Oregon State
A month ago, Oregon State was the talk of the G6 landscape, as the Beavers were 5-2 with both losses coming to ranked Big 12 teams (Houston and Texas Tech). Since then, the Beavers have dropped three in a row to fall out of contention in the reconstituted Pac-12 and put themselves in danger of missing out on a bowl game. The defense has been particularly problematic, allowing 156 points over their past four games. If not for the presence of Colorado State, and their middle school caliber defense, the Beavers would have the worst per play defense in the conference. Thanks to the historical levels of atrociousness in Fort Collins, the Beavers are somehow almost two and half yards per play better than the Rams defensively. In their final scheduled game (the Pac-12 debuts their flex scheduling next week), the Beavers face the best defense in the conference in Utah State. The Aggies slipped a bit against San Diego State last week, but they are still allowing under five yards per play to conference opponents and should be able to hold Oregon State below their offensive season averages. I think the Beavers will also come out a little flat after expending a great deal of energy in nearly upsetting Boise State on the Smurf Turf last weekend. Utah State does not have the offense to keep up with the Beavers, so they need for this game to be played in the high teens or low twenties. If the Beavers get to thirty, they will cover easily, but I think the Utes are able to ugly things up and keep this one low-scoring.
Hawaii -4 Nevada
This is the last game to kick on Saturday night, so you may want to get in a nap at some point in the afternoon. This is a rough travel spot for Hawaii as they are back on the mainland for the second time in three weeks after visiting El Paso, hosting North Dakota State, and now traveling to the biggest little city in the world. Handicapping motivation can be hard, but I think Nevada will have more of it. The Wolfpack still have a shot at bowl eligibility if they can beat the Warriors and then win their rivalry game with UNLV next week. Meanwhile, Hawaii is locked in to a losing season after losing a close home game to the Bison last week. Hawaii's three wins on the year have all come against teams of varying shades of terrible (New Mexico State, Northern Illinois, and UTEP). They did manage to win two of those on the road, but their other road games have not gone well, with each loss coming by at least ten points. Nevada has not played in a bowl game since 2021 and already has their most victories under head coach Jeff Choate. They should get to victory number five relatively easily here and set themselves up for a massive battle for the Fremont Cannon with UNLV next week.
.jpg)